Can EMDR Be Adapted for People Who Dissociate?
Short Answer: Yes, Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) can be adapted for people who experience dissociation. Dissociation involves feeling disconnected from thoughts, emotions, memories, the body, or present surroundings. Some people experience occasional disconnection, while others have more persistent dissociative symptoms. EMDR adaptations may include additional preparation, grounding exercises, shorter periods of memory processing, and adjustments to the pace of sessions. The goal is to help the person remain sufficiently connected to the present while working with distressing memories. The most appropriate approach depends on the type and extent of dissociation, individual readiness, and whether specialized therapist guidance is needed.
Key Takeaways
- EMDR can be adapted for people who experience dissociation, although the approach depends on individual needs.
- Dissociation can involve feeling detached from emotions, memories, the body, or surrounding environment.
- Additional preparation and grounding techniques may help maintain present-moment awareness during EMDR.
- Shorter processing periods and a slower pace may be useful when someone has difficulty staying connected to the present.
- EMDR therapists may modify memory selection, bilateral stimulation, and session structure.
- Persistent or complex dissociative symptoms may require assessment and specialized therapist guidance.
- Dissociation does not automatically mean EMDR is unsuitable, but it can influence how treatment is planned.
What Is Dissociation?
Dissociation is a term used to describe a sense of disconnection from aspects of experience, such as thoughts, emotions, memories, physical sensations, or the surrounding environment.
Dissociative experiences can vary considerably.
For example, someone may occasionally feel emotionally detached while remembering a stressful event. Another person may experience a stronger sense of separation from their body or surroundings.
Possible experiences include:
- Emotional Disconnection: Feeling unusually detached from emotions that would normally be associated with an experience.
- Feeling Disconnected From the Body: Experiencing a sense of distance from physical sensations or bodily awareness.
- Altered Awareness of Surroundings: Feeling that the environment seems distant, unfamiliar, or unreal.
- Memory Gaps: Having difficulty recalling certain periods or aspects of an experience.
- Difficulty Staying Present: Finding it challenging to remain fully aware of current surroundings during emotionally difficult moments.
These experiences are not all equally common, and having one does not necessarily indicate a dissociative disorder.
Dissociation can occur in different contexts and may sometimes function as a response to overwhelming experiences.
Understanding how dissociation affects an individual is important when deciding whether and how to adapt EMDR.
How Can Dissociation Affect EMDR Processing?
EMDR involves focusing on a distressing memory while using bilateral stimulation, such as guided eye movements, alternating sounds, or tapping.
During processing, a person notices thoughts, emotions, images, and physical sensations while remaining aware of the present.
This ability to maintain awareness of both the memory and current surroundings is called dual attention.
For example, someone may remember a frightening event while recognizing that they are sitting in a room where the event is no longer taking place.
Dissociation can sometimes make this process more difficult.
A person may become less aware of their surroundings, feel emotionally disconnected from the memory, or find it difficult to describe what they are experiencing.
These responses may affect how the processing session unfolds.
Rather than assuming that the standard pace and structure will work for everyone, EMDR can be adjusted to better accommodate the person's ability to remain present.
The goal is to support meaningful memory processing while respecting individual differences in how distressing experiences are recalled.
Why Is Additional Preparation Sometimes Helpful?
Preparation is an established phase of EMDR treatment.
It may include learning about the process, developing grounding techniques, identifying coping strategies, and understanding how to pause or stop processing.
For people who experience dissociation, preparation may receive additional attention.
For example, someone who frequently feels disconnected from their surroundings when recalling difficult memories may benefit from practicing ways to reconnect with the present.
Preparation may also involve recognizing early signs of disconnection and identifying strategies that help restore awareness.
These skills can be practiced before detailed memory processing begins.
The amount of preparation needed depends on the individual's experiences.
Someone with occasional, mild dissociative symptoms may require different adjustments from someone with frequent or complex dissociation.
Spending more time on preparation does not mean that EMDR has been unsuccessful or that progress has stopped.
It may simply be part of establishing an appropriate foundation for processing.
How Can Grounding Techniques Be Used During EMDR?
Grounding techniques help direct attention toward the present environment.
They can be particularly useful when someone experiences a sense of disconnection while discussing or recalling distressing material.
Examples include:
- Noticing Surroundings: Looking around the room and identifying familiar objects.
- Physical Contact: Paying attention to the feeling of feet resting on the floor or hands touching a chair.
- Sensory Awareness: Noticing sounds, textures, or other features of the current environment.
- Gentle Movement: Stretching or changing position to help reconnect with bodily awareness.
- Present-Moment Reminders: Identifying the current location, date, or other details that distinguish the present from a remembered event.
Not every grounding technique works equally well for everyone.
Some people may find visual or physical grounding more useful than exercises involving internal sensations.
The aim is to identify approaches that help the individual maintain or regain awareness of the present.
In therapist-guided EMDR, grounding techniques can be incorporated into preparation and used when needed during sessions.
Can EMDR Processing Be Slowed Down for Dissociation?
Yes. Adjusting the pace is one way EMDR may be adapted for someone who experiences dissociation.
Standard EMDR involves periods of bilateral stimulation followed by opportunities to notice what has changed.
For some individuals, shorter processing periods or more frequent pauses may help maintain awareness of the present.
For example, a therapist may use shorter sets of bilateral stimulation and check more frequently whether the person remains connected to their surroundings.
The therapist may also slow the progression through distressing material or return to grounding before continuing.
These adjustments allow the person's responses to guide the pace of treatment.
Slower processing does not necessarily mean less meaningful processing.
The purpose is to find a pace that supports attention, emotional regulation, and the ability to remain engaged with the experience.
Can the Choice of Memory Be Adjusted?
Memory selection is another area where EMDR may be adapted.
EMDR commonly involves identifying a specific distressing memory, sometimes called a target memory.
For someone experiencing dissociation, the choice of memory may be particularly important.
A therapist may begin by exploring which experiences can be recalled while the person maintains adequate awareness of the present.
Rather than immediately focusing on the most emotionally difficult experience, treatment may initially address more manageable material.
The therapist may also work with a smaller aspect of a memory instead of attempting to process a broad collection of experiences at once.
This approach can help establish familiarity with the processing procedure and provide opportunities to evaluate readiness.
Memory selection should reflect the individual's treatment goals and circumstances.
The aim is not necessarily to avoid difficult memories indefinitely, but to approach them in an appropriate sequence.
What About Changes to Bilateral Stimulation?
Bilateral stimulation is a central component of EMDR and may involve eye movements, alternating sounds, or tapping.
The method and settings can sometimes be adjusted according to individual needs.
For example, an EMDR therapist may change the duration of stimulation sets, the speed of eye movements, or the method used.
These adjustments may help the person maintain attention and remain connected to the present.
However, there is no single bilateral stimulation setting that has been established as ideal for everyone who dissociates.
Different individuals may respond differently to the same method.
For this reason, adjustments should be based on the person's experience rather than assuming that a particular speed or stimulation type will automatically resolve dissociation.
In more complex cases, decisions about these modifications are best made within an individualized treatment plan.
How Can Someone Recognize Dissociation During a Session?
Recognizing personal signs of dissociation can help guide decisions about pacing and preparation.
Some people notice changes in their awareness when discussing distressing experiences.
For example, a person might find that their surroundings suddenly seem distant or that they have difficulty following the conversation.
Others may notice emotional numbness, reduced awareness of physical sensations, or trouble describing what they are experiencing.
These changes do not always mean that dissociation is occurring. Similar experiences can have other explanations.
However, when someone recognizes a familiar pattern of disconnection, it may be useful to pause and reorient toward the present.
In therapist-guided EMDR, discussing these experiences helps the therapist understand whether the current approach needs adjustment.
Learning to recognize individual patterns can also become part of EMDR preparation.
Is EMDR Different for People With Complex Dissociation?
Some people experience occasional dissociation, while others have more persistent symptoms that substantially affect memory, awareness, or their sense of identity.
These situations may require different approaches.
When dissociation is frequent, pronounced, or associated with a diagnosed dissociative disorder, EMDR treatment may involve a longer preparation phase and more individualized modifications.
A therapist experienced in both EMDR and dissociation can assess the person's symptoms, readiness, and ability to remain connected to the present during processing.
Treatment may involve working on emotional regulation, strengthening grounding skills, and selecting memories carefully before proceeding with detailed trauma processing.
Specialized clinical guidelines recommend adapting EMDR within a broader treatment plan for people with complex dissociative disorders.
Importantly, experiencing occasional detachment or emotional numbness does not automatically mean someone has such a disorder.
The type and extent of dissociation matter when determining the appropriate approach.
What About Self-Guided or Online EMDR?
EMDR can take place through therapist-guided sessions in person, therapist-guided video appointments, or self-guided online programs.
For example, Virtual EMDR is a structured, self-guided online EMDR program in which users manage their own sessions rather than working with a therapist in real time.
Self-guided sessions allow users to control available pacing settings, take breaks, and stop when needed.
However, managing dissociation involves more than adjusting the speed or duration of bilateral stimulation.
People who frequently lose awareness of their surroundings, experience significant memory gaps, or have persistent difficulty staying present may benefit from an assessment by a therapist familiar with dissociation before attempting independent memory processing.
A therapist can evaluate whether adaptations beyond those available in a self-guided program are needed.
For people who experience occasional, mild disconnection, learning grounding techniques and understanding session controls may be helpful preparation.
The important distinction is between being able to adjust a self-guided session and receiving individualized clinical treatment for complex dissociative symptoms.
Does Dissociation Mean EMDR Cannot Work?
No. Dissociation does not automatically rule out EMDR.
However, dissociative symptoms may influence the preparation, structure, and timing of treatment.
Some people may be able to participate in EMDR with relatively modest adjustments, while others may require more extensive preparation and specialized guidance.
Clinical literature describes adapted EMDR approaches for people with dissociative symptoms, although evidence for specific adaptations and complex dissociative disorders remains more limited than the broader evidence supporting EMDR for post-traumatic stress disorder.
The goal is to determine which approach is appropriate for the individual's needs rather than applying the same procedure to everyone.
Conclusion
EMDR can be adapted for people who experience dissociation by adjusting preparation, pacing, grounding techniques, memory selection, and the structure of processing sessions.
The most appropriate adaptations depend on how dissociation affects the individual's awareness, emotional responses, and ability to remain connected to the present.
Some people may need relatively minor adjustments, while others may benefit from longer preparation and specialized therapist guidance.
Dissociation does not automatically make EMDR unsuitable. Understanding the person's experiences and adapting the approach accordingly can help support appropriately paced trauma processing.
View Comments