What If a Different Memory Becomes More Important During EMDR?
Short Answer: If a different memory starts to feel more important during EMDR, notice it without assuming you must immediately change your target. Memories can connect through feelings, beliefs, or details, and another experience can come to mind as processing unfolds. Follow the instructions for the stage of your session, describe what you notice, and distinguish a passing association from a memory you want to address more directly. You can make a note of the new memory and decide how to approach it at an appropriate point in the process.
Key Takeaways
- A different memory can come to mind while you are working with your original EMDR target.
- A memory that feels more important is not automatically the one you need to switch to immediately.
- Notice the connection, follow the current session instructions, and record useful details without forcing a decision.
- You can revisit target selection at an appropriate point instead of changing direction in the middle of every round.
Why Can Another Memory Come to Mind During EMDR?
EMDR often begins with a particular memory or situation chosen as the target. As you focus on that experience, another memory can appear. It might involve a similar feeling, a familiar thought about yourself, or a detail that reminds you of something else. The connection is not always obvious at first.
For example, you might begin with a difficult conversation at work and remember an earlier occasion when you felt dismissed. The newer conversation remains the selected target, but the older memory now has your attention. This does not necessarily mean you chose the wrong starting point.
Associations can shift during processing. Sometimes they are brief and your attention returns to the original memory. At other times, the new memory stays prominent. The useful first step is to recognize what appeared rather than immediately deciding what it means.
You do not have to explain why the memories are connected while the round is underway. Noticing the new image, feeling, or thought is enough to describe what happened.
Does the New Memory Have to Replace the Original Target?
No. A memory becoming noticeable or emotionally significant does not automatically make it the next target. Your original memory was selected for a reason, and a structured EMDR session has steps for working with it.
An association can be part of processing the original target rather than a request to abandon it. If the session asks what you noticed, you can describe the different memory as part of your response. You do not need to decide on the spot that the entire session should change direction.
There are also times when a newly remembered event deserves attention in its own right. That is a question about planning and selecting a target, not something a single moment of intensity can answer by itself.
Treat the new memory as useful information. It can be important without requiring an immediate change in the process you are following.
How Can You Tell Whether It Is an Association or a New Priority?
An association is a memory, image, or thought that appears while you are focusing on something else. It might pass quickly, or it might return more than once. A new priority is a memory you deliberately choose to address as a target after considering how it fits your goals and the session plan.
The difference is not simply which memory feels stronger in a particular moment. A vivid detail can attract attention without becoming the best place to begin a separate round of work. Likewise, a quieter memory can still matter to your overall goals.
Ask yourself what actually happened. Did another memory appear briefly while the original target remained clear? Did the session prompt you to notice whatever came up? Or have you reached a point where the process invites you to review your target?
These questions help separate observation from decision-making. You can acknowledge that a different memory stands out without treating that feeling as an instruction to switch immediately.
What Should You Do When the Different Memory Appears?
During a processing round, follow the instructions you have been given. If another memory comes up, notice it. When asked what you experienced, describe it plainly. You can say that a different event came to mind or that your attention shifted toward a particular detail.
Try not to spend the round comparing which memory is more important. Repeatedly evaluating the two experiences can turn your attention toward making a decision instead of observing what comes up.
If the instructions direct you to return to a designated target, do that. If they direct you to notice the next association, follow that step instead. Different parts of a structured session serve different purposes, so the current instruction matters more than a general rule to always stay or always switch.
You can remember a short phrase about the new memory for later. There is no need to reconstruct every detail or work out its meaning while the session is still moving.
What If the New Memory Feels More Upsetting?
A different memory can feel more upsetting than the one you originally selected. That contrast can make it seem as though the new memory must be more important. But emotional intensity is only one part of understanding what you want to work on.
Notice the change without trying to increase or reduce the feeling. If the session includes a check-in, answer based on the memory or target the question is asking about. A rating for one memory should not silently become a rating for another.
If your attention has moved so far that you are no longer sure what you are rating or following, pause at an appropriate point and review the instructions. You can describe the shift accurately rather than guessing which memory the session expects.
A stronger reaction is not a deadline to change targets. You can take the new memory seriously and still choose a deliberate next step.
Can Two Memories Be Connected Without Being the Same Target?
Yes. Two experiences can share a feeling or belief while remaining separate events. A disagreement with a friend might bring up an earlier time when you felt excluded. Both experiences can matter, but they do not become one memory simply because they are connected.
It helps to keep the distinction clear when you describe what happened. The original target is the event you selected to work on. The second memory is something that appeared during the process. Keeping those descriptions separate makes your observations easier to understand.
You do not need to prove a connection or decide that one memory caused your response to the other. A link that seems meaningful can be noted without turning it into a firm explanation.
If you later decide to address the second memory directly, you can consider it as its own target within the process you are using. That decision is different from simply noticing the association.
When Is It Helpful to Revisit Your Target Choice?
Target selection is easier to consider when you are not trying to complete a processing round at the same time. A natural opportunity is during session planning, a scheduled review, or after the current session has been closed appropriately.
At that point, look at what you intended to address and what the new memory brought to your attention. You might decide the original target still fits your goal. You might also decide the new memory deserves a future session. Neither choice has to be made solely because one memory briefly felt stronger.
If you are working with a therapist, you can describe the new memory and discuss how it relates to the existing plan. If you are using a structured self-guided program such as Virtual EMDR, you can record the memory and use the program’s target-selection and session instructions when deciding what to work on next.
In either format, the purpose is to make a considered choice rather than repeatedly changing targets whenever a new association appears.
Should You Write Down the New Memory?
A brief note can help if you want to remember the new memory after the session. Write a few words identifying the event and, if useful, the feeling or thought that connected it to the original target.
Keep the note short enough that it does not become a second processing exercise. You do not need to produce a complete timeline, explain every connection, or assign a disturbance rating unless the session specifically calls for one.
For example, you might write that a childhood classroom memory came up while working on a present-day criticism. That is enough to remind you what you noticed without claiming that the two events have a definite explanation.
If nothing about the new memory feels useful to record, you do not have to make a note. The goal is to support your next decision, not to document every passing association.
What If You Keep Moving Between Different Memories?
Sometimes attention moves back and forth between the original target and several other experiences. That can make it hard to tell which memory you are focusing on. Instead of trying to sort them all out during a round, notice the pattern and return to the instruction for the current stage.
If the process asks you to report what came up, you can say that your attention moved among memories. You do not need to choose a single explanation or pretend that only one event appeared.
If you repeatedly lose track of the selected target or the session step, a pause can help you orient yourself. Check what the session is asking you to do and whether you want to continue at that point. Finishing appropriately is also an option when the session is ready to end.
Multiple memories appearing does not mean you must process them all in one sitting. You can keep a clear record of the original target and decide later whether any of the other memories should become separate targets.
Conclusion
When a different memory becomes more important during EMDR, the first task is to notice the shift, not to force an immediate change of target. The new memory might be a passing association, a meaningful connection, or an experience you choose to address later. Its appearance alone does not decide which one it is.
Follow the instructions for the stage of your session, describe what you actually notice, and keep the original target clear when answering questions about it. If the new memory remains important, make a brief note and revisit your target choice at an appropriate time. This allows you to take the new experience seriously without losing the structure of the session.
View Comments