KNOWLEDGE BASE

What If the Disturbance Does Not Change During EMDR?

Understanding why disturbance ratings may remain unchanged during EMDR and how to respond without forcing a lower score.


17 Nov 2026

Tag:

A man wearing a blue plaid shirt and carrying a shoulder bag stands in a corridor holding an open notebook and several books.

An unchanged disturbance rating during EMDR does not automatically mean a lack of progress. The number is one part of assessing your response to a memory.

What If the Disturbance Does Not Change During EMDR?

Short Answer: If your disturbance rating stays the same during EMDR, it does not automatically mean the session is failing. The number describes how upsetting a particular memory feels at the moment you check it. Sometimes the rating stays steady while you notice other changes, and sometimes very little seems to change during a particular round. Recheck the same target, give an honest rating, and follow the session process without trying to force a lower number. You can also pause or finish when appropriate.

Key Takeaways

  • An unchanged disturbance rating is information about the moment, not proof that EMDR is not working.
  • Use the same memory and rating question when comparing numbers so the comparison is meaningful.
  • Notice changes in thoughts, feelings, images, or body sensations without forcing the rating to move.
  • Follow the session structure and your own pace rather than repeating rounds simply to obtain a lower score.

What Does an Unchanged Disturbance Rating Mean?

In EMDR, a disturbance rating is a way of describing how upsetting a selected memory feels when you bring it to mind. The commonly used Subjective Units of Disturbance scale runs from zero, meaning no disturbance, to ten, meaning the highest disturbance you can imagine. It is a personal estimate rather than a test with a right answer.

If you rate a memory as a five, complete a round of processing, and still rate it as a five, you have reported that the distress feels about the same on that scale. That is all the number establishes. It does not tell the whole story of what you noticed during the round or predict what will happen next.

A rating is also a snapshot. You are not expected to produce a smooth sequence of numbers that decreases after every round. Keeping the rating honest is more useful than adjusting it because you think it ought to change.

Why Might the Number Stay the Same?

One reason is that the aspect of the memory you are rating still feels equally upsetting. You might have noticed a thought or an image during processing without experiencing a noticeable change in distress. A new observation does not always translate into a new number immediately.

Another reason is that the scale is fairly broad. A small shift in how you feel might not be enough to move your rating from five to four. The number is an approximation, so two slightly different experiences can reasonably receive the same rating.

You might also be thinking about a different part of the experience when you check again. If the focus changes from one upsetting detail to another, the rating can remain steady even though your attention has shifted. This is why it helps to understand exactly what you are rating.

Finally, a single round is only one part of a structured session. It is not a requirement that every round produce a visible change in the number.

Does a Steady Rating Mean EMDR Is Not Working?

No single rating can establish whether EMDR is helping. EMDR involves a structured process, and a disturbance score is one of the ways the experience is checked along the way. It is not a pass-or-fail mark for an individual round.

For example, you might still rate a memory as six but notice that one image seems less sharp, that your thoughts about it are different, or that your attention has moved to another detail. Those observations are worth noticing even when the numerical rating remains six.

The opposite can happen too. You might notice little difference in the memory or in your rating during a particular session. It is better to acknowledge that accurately than to search for a hidden sign of progress. An unchanged rating is not a reason to invent a change that you do not feel.

What matters is looking at the experience in context rather than using one number to judge the entire session.

Make Sure You Are Rating the Same Target

Before comparing two disturbance ratings, check that you are considering the same target memory or aspect of the memory. The question is usually how disturbing that target feels now when you bring it to mind.

Imagine that you started with a memory of an argument. At first, the most upsetting part was a particular sentence. Later, you began thinking about the expression on the other person’s face. Both details belong to the same event, but they can carry different levels of distress.

If you switch between those details without noticing, a repeated number can be difficult to interpret. You may not actually be comparing the same experience. Return to the target specified in the session instructions and answer the rating question as it is asked.

There is no need to analyze every detail until you find a lower score. The aim is consistency and an honest description of your response.

Notice What Changes Besides the Number

When the disturbance score does not move, pay attention to what you genuinely noticed during processing. Perhaps the image stayed the same while a different thought came to mind. Perhaps a body sensation changed, or the memory felt easier to describe. Perhaps nothing obvious changed at all.

These observations can help you understand the session, but they are not substitutes for the disturbance rating. A shift in one part of your experience does not require you to report a lower number if the memory still feels just as upsetting.

Likewise, a steady number does not erase changes you did notice. Both pieces of information can be true at the same time. The memory may feel equally disturbing on the scale while some of its details are experienced differently.

Try to observe rather than evaluate. You do not need to decide that every new thought is important or that every unchanged sensation is a problem.

What Should You Do During the Next Round?

If the session is still underway and its instructions call for another round, continue with the process you are following. Bring the designated target to mind as directed, notice what comes up, and report your experience accurately when asked.

Avoid deliberately trying to make the number drop. Repeating a reassuring phrase, changing the rating to sound more successful, or searching for a different memory just to obtain a smaller score can make the rating less useful.

It also helps not to check the number constantly between the points where the session asks you to assess it. Frequent self-testing can pull attention away from the exercise itself. Let the structured check-ins do their job.

Whether you're working with a therapist or using an online self-guided program like Virtual EMDR, the same principle applies when your disturbance rating stays unchanged. You do not need to make the number decrease after every round. What matters is accurately noticing how the memory feels as you move through the EMDR process.

What If the Rating Remains the Same for Several Rounds?

If the rating stays unchanged through several checks, first consider whether you are using the scale consistently and focusing on the same target. You can also notice whether your thoughts, emotions, images, or body sensations have shifted even if the number has not.

A steady rating does not create an obligation to continue indefinitely. The number alone is not a reason to add extra rounds beyond the session structure or to push past the point when you want to stop.

In therapist-led EMDR, the therapist can use your observations and the overall session process to decide what comes next with you. In self-guided EMDR, use the program’s instructions and available options for pausing, ending, or returning another time.

If you repeatedly find yourself unsure how to proceed, that is a practical reason to review the instructions or consider additional guidance. It does not mean the unchanged rating itself is a warning sign.

Can You Finish a Session Without a Lower Rating?

Yes. A session can come to an end even when a disturbance rating has not decreased. A time limit, the stage of the session, or your decision to stop can all affect when you finish. Ending a session is not the same thing as declaring that the memory has been fully processed.

EMDR protocols include ways of closing a session when processing is not complete. If you are working with a therapist, they can guide that closing process. If you are using a structured online program, follow its ending and grounding instructions rather than simply trying to make the rating change at the last minute.

You can record the rating you actually reached and any useful observations about the target. That provides a straightforward reference if you return to the memory in a later session.

There is no benefit in calling a five a three just to finish with a more satisfying number. A truthful record is more useful than a tidy-looking result.

How Can You Think About Progress Over Time?

It is natural to want evidence that an EMDR session is helping, especially when you have been paying attention to the same distressing memory. Still, one repeated rating offers only a limited view of the process.

Over time, you can compare how the same target feels when you revisit it and note whether your reactions to the memory have changed. The disturbance scale gives you one way to describe those reactions, alongside your own observations.

Try not to compare your numbers with someone else’s or assume that progress must happen at a particular speed. Two people can begin with the same rating and have very different experiences during processing.

If you keep notes, make them simple. The target, the rating when checked, and a brief description of what you noticed are enough. The notes are there to help you remember the session, not to turn it into a performance review.

Conclusion

When the disturbance does not change during EMDR, the most useful response is to treat the rating as an honest snapshot rather than a verdict on your progress. A steady number can occur alongside other observations, or it can reflect that the memory still feels much the same.

Check that you are rating the same target, follow the session instructions, and avoid trying to force a lower score. You can continue when the process calls for it or finish the session appropriately when it is time to stop. The goal is to understand your experience, not to make the numbers behave in a particular way.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal for my disturbance rating to stay the same? +
Yes. A rating does not have to change after every round of EMDR. It reflects how disturbing the target feels when you check it.
Should I change my rating if I notice a new thought? +
Not unless the target actually feels different on the disturbance scale. A new thought and an unchanged rating can occur together.
Does a rating that stays at five mean I am stuck? +
Not necessarily. It means you are still describing the target as a five at that check. Consider the full session rather than interpreting one number as a final result.
Should I keep doing more rounds until the number drops? +
Follow the session structure rather than adding rounds simply to chase a lower score. You can pause or end a session appropriately even if the number has not moved.
Can I return to the same memory in another session? +
Yes, when it fits the process you are following. Recording the target and your actual rating can help you remember where you left off.

Related Articles

Woman smiling outdoors beside a lake surrounded by trees

What Does Progress in EMDR Look Like?

Progress in EMDR can appear in different ways, from a memory feeling less distressing or immediate to changes in beliefs, physical reactions, triggers, avoidance, and everyday behavior. This article explains how both gradual and noticeable shifts can be meaningful signs of progress.

Read more
Hands holding soil with a small green seedling growing in warm sunlight.

What If the Target Memory Changes During EMDR?

If the memory you started with changes during Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), that does not necessarily mean you have lost focus or are doing anything wrong. Another memory, image, thought, feeling, or detail may come to mind as the session continues. You can notice what has co

Read more
Empty park path with a bench surrounded by green trees and grass under a bright blue sky.

What Happens at the End of an EMDR Session

At the end of an Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) session, you stop the active processing, notice how you are feeling, and bring the session to a clear stopping point. In the standard eight-phase EMDR process, this is called closure. If you finished processing the target, you may

Read more
Group of puppies resting together on an outdoor sofa, representing gradual growth and progress continuing over time.

Can EMDR Progress Continue Between Sessions?

Yes. Progress from Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) may continue to become noticeable between sessions. You might find that a memory feels less upsetting when you think about it later, that your perspective on an experience changes, or that a situation that used to bother you fee

Read more