KNOWLEDGE BASE

What If the Disturbance Goes Up During EMDR?

Understanding why disturbance ratings can increase during EMDR and how to respond without forcing the number down.


17 Nov 2026

Tag:

A smiling woman with curly hair reaching her hand toward the camera outdoors beside a body of water.

An increase in disturbance during EMDR does not automatically mean a setback. Ratings can change as different aspects of a memory come into focus.

What If the Disturbance Goes Up During EMDR?

Short Answer: A disturbance rating can go up during EMDR, even after it has started to decrease. This does not automatically mean that the session is going badly or that you have lost progress. As you focus on a memory, you may notice another part of the experience or become more aware of a feeling that was already there. The rating describes how upsetting the memory feels at that moment. Notice the change, use the session’s normal reassessment steps, and adjust the pace if needed rather than treating a higher number as a problem you must immediately fix.

Key Takeaways

  • Disturbance ratings can rise or fall during EMDR rather than decreasing in a straight line.
  • A higher number is a description of how the memory feels now, not a score for how well you are doing.
  • A new detail, thought, or feeling can temporarily change how you rate the same memory.
  • Pay attention to your experience and the session structure instead of trying to force the number down.

Why Can Disturbance Increase During Processing?

EMDR involves bringing a selected memory or experience to mind while following a structured process that includes bilateral stimulation and periodic checks of what you notice. At the beginning of a session, you may rate the disturbance at one level and then give it a higher number later. The change can be surprising if you expected the number to move steadily toward zero.

A memory is not always experienced in exactly the same way each time you think about it. At first, you might be focused on one image or one part of what happened. As processing continues, a different detail, emotion, or body sensation can stand out. Your rating can change because what you are noticing has changed.

Sometimes the memory feels more upsetting because you are paying closer attention to it. Sometimes a thought that seemed unimportant at first becomes more meaningful. These possibilities do not tell you exactly what is happening in any particular session, but they help explain why the rating is not always a smooth downward line.

The purpose of checking disturbance is to understand your current response to the target memory. It is not to make every check lower than the last one. A temporary increase gives you information about the experience you are having at that point.

What Does the Disturbance Number Actually Measure?

In EMDR, disturbance is commonly rated using the Subjective Units of Disturbance scale, often shortened to SUD. The scale usually runs from zero, meaning no disturbance, to ten, meaning the highest disturbance you can imagine. You use it to describe how upsetting the target feels right now, not how upsetting it was when the event originally happened.

For example, you might begin at a four, notice a stronger feeling during processing, and rate the memory at a six. The six does not erase the earlier four. Each rating is a snapshot taken at a different moment. The numbers are useful because they help you notice changes, but they are still personal estimates rather than precise measurements.

Two people can respond to similar memories with different ratings. Even your own sense of what a four or six feels like can vary slightly from one check to another. That is why the number is most helpful when considered alongside what you actually notice, such as a change in the image, emotion, or meaning of the memory.

Does a Higher Rating Mean EMDR Is Not Working?

No. A higher disturbance rating on its own is not enough to decide whether EMDR is helping. EMDR processing is not evaluated by a single number taken in the middle of a session. A rating can rise before it falls, stay similar for a while, or change in smaller steps.

It is understandable to compare each new rating with the previous one. But treating every increase as a setback can distract you from what the session is asking you to notice. The more useful question is what feels different now. You might be aware of a new thought, a stronger feeling, or an aspect of the memory you had not been focusing on earlier.

A rising rating also does not prove that something important has been uncovered. There is no need to search for a hidden explanation just because the number changed. Sometimes the simplest explanation is that the same memory feels more upsetting at this particular moment.

Rather than drawing a conclusion from one increase, follow the planned reassessment process and consider the broader pattern of your experience.

What If the Rating Goes From Three to Seven?

A noticeable jump can feel different from a small change. If you rated a memory at three and then at seven, first recognize that seven is your current estimate. You do not need to defend the number, minimize it, or immediately make it lower.

Notice what you are experiencing as you give that rating. Is the image clearer? Has your attention moved to a different moment? Is a particular feeling more noticeable? You do not have to analyze every possibility. A brief observation can be enough to understand what you are responding to.

Then use the steps built into the EMDR session. If you are working with a therapist, you can tell them the new rating and what changed. If you are using a structured self-guided session, follow its prompts for checking your experience and deciding what to do next. Both approaches use the rating as feedback rather than as a demand to reach a certain number immediately.

If the experience feels too uncomfortable to continue at that moment, pausing is a reasonable choice. You can return to the session when you feel ready, without needing to treat the pause as a failure.

Can a New Memory Detail Change the Rating?

Yes. The disturbance rating applies to how the target memory feels as you bring it to mind. If you begin noticing a different part of that memory, the emotional response can change too. You might start with an image of a conversation and later focus on a particular sentence that still bothers you. The rating may be higher because that detail feels more upsetting.

This does not mean you must deliberately look for more distressing details. EMDR is not a test of how much discomfort you can find. The point is to notice what comes up during the structured process and respond to it in a measured way.

It can also help to distinguish a change in the same target from a shift to an entirely different issue. If your attention has moved to another memory, the rating may no longer be describing precisely the same thing you rated at the start. Keeping track of what you are rating makes the numbers easier to interpret.

Should You Keep Going Until the Number Drops Again?

Not simply because the rating went up. EMDR sessions have a structure, and the next step depends on where you are in that process, what you are noticing, and whether continuing feels manageable. Repeating stimulation only to get a lower number can turn a useful check-in into pressure to produce a particular result.

If you feel comfortable and the session calls for another round, you can continue according to that structure. If you want a break, you can pause. You do not have to choose between pushing through and abandoning the work entirely. Slowing the pace or stopping for the day can be a practical response to how you feel.

In therapist-led EMDR, the therapist helps guide the timing and reassessment. In an online self-guided program such as Virtual EMDR, the person follows the program’s structured prompts. In either format, the basic principle is the same. Use the disturbance rating to understand the experience, not as a number to chase.

What If the Rating Keeps Going Up?

If several checks in a row are higher, avoid assuming that the next one must be higher too. Ratings describe the present moment, not a prediction. Instead, consider whether you are still focusing on the intended target and whether the session remains comfortable enough to continue.

You can pause and orient yourself to the room around you. Notice the chair beneath you, the floor under your feet, and the ordinary details of your surroundings. A short break gives you space to decide whether you want to resume. These are simple ways to interrupt the exercise when you no longer want to continue at the same pace.

If you are working with a therapist, explain what you are noticing so the next steps can be adjusted together. If you are working independently and find that you repeatedly cannot settle enough to follow the session, consider using additional support before returning to that particular target.

A rising rating is not, by itself, a reason to become alarmed. It is a reason to pay attention to what is happening and make a choice that fits the moment.

Can Disturbance Go Up Even When You Feel Calmer Overall?

Yes. Your overall mood and your disturbance rating are not necessarily the same thing. You might feel relatively settled while sitting in the room, yet still find that the specific memory is upsetting when you bring it to mind. The rating is about the target memory at the time of the check, not a general measure of how calm you feel throughout the day.

The reverse can happen too. You might feel nervous about doing a session while the memory itself produces only a low disturbance rating. Keeping these experiences separate can make your check-ins more accurate.

When you rate the target, briefly return your attention to the memory and notice how it feels now. You do not need to exaggerate the response or try to create distress. Give the number that best matches what you genuinely experience.

How to Respond Without Focusing Too Much on the Number

The rating is one part of EMDR, not the whole process. If you become preoccupied with whether the number is going up or down, it can help to return to the immediate question the session is asking. What do you notice now? That observation may be more useful than comparing every number in isolation.

Use the same target when making comparisons whenever possible. Be straightforward about changes in the memory or feeling. If you are unsure whether the rating is a five or a six, choose the number that seems closest and move on. The scale is intended to support awareness, not demand mathematical precision.

You can also remember that progress is not measured by how quickly you report zero. Some sessions involve more changes than others. The goal is to follow the process thoughtfully and respond to your experience, not to make the rating look better on paper.

Conclusion

A disturbance rating that goes up during EMDR is not automatically a setback. It can reflect a change in what you notice, how strongly a detail affects you, or how the target memory feels at that moment. One higher number does not determine the outcome of the session.

Whether you are doing EMDR with a therapist or independently, use the rating as information. Follow the session structure, notice what has changed, and adjust your pace when needed. You do not have to force the disturbance down or treat a temporary increase as proof that anything has gone wrong.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal for disturbance to increase during EMDR? +
Disturbance can increase during processing. The rating reflects how the target feels at a particular moment, and that response can change as you notice different aspects of the memory.
Does a higher disturbance score mean I am losing progress? +
Not necessarily. One higher rating does not establish that earlier work has been lost. Look at what you are noticing and follow the session’s reassessment steps rather than judging progress from a single check.
Should I stop EMDR if my disturbance rating rises? +
A rise alone does not mean you have to stop. You can continue according to the session structure if you feel comfortable, or pause if you would prefer a break.
Why did my rating rise when I was feeling calm? +
Feeling calm in general and feeling disturbed by a specific memory are different experiences. The rating asks how upsetting the target feels when you bring it to mind.
Do I need to reach zero in the same session? +
You do not need to force a zero rating by extending a session beyond what feels manageable. Follow the process you are using and assess the target honestly rather than choosing a number you think you are supposed to reach.

Related Articles

Smiling man and woman looking at a tablet together in a library, reflecting a calm and positive experience.

Can EMDR Bring Up a Memory Without Making It More Disturbing?

Yes. Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) can bring a memory to mind without making it more disturbing. During EMDR, you may remember an experience, notice a detail you had not thought about recently, or become aware of a connection between memories. That memory does not necessarily

Read more
Woman smiling outdoors beside a lake surrounded by trees

What Does Progress in EMDR Look Like?

Progress in EMDR can appear in different ways, from a memory feeling less distressing or immediate to changes in beliefs, physical reactions, triggers, avoidance, and everyday behavior. This article explains how both gradual and noticeable shifts can be meaningful signs of progress.

Read more
Man sitting quietly on the floor at home, representing a pause during a self-guided EMDR session.

When Should You Pause Self-Guided EMDR?

You can pause self-guided Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) whenever you want. A pause may make sense if you are having trouble focusing, feel more uncomfortable than you want to continue with, become tired or distracted, get interrupted, or simply decide you have done enough for

Read more
Woman wearing headphones during a self-guided EMDR session at home using a laptop

What Is the SUD Scale in EMDR?

  The SUD scale in EMDR is a simple 0-to-10 rating used to describe how disturbing a memory, thought, image, or other focus feels to you right now. SUD stands for Subjective Units of Disturbance. A rating of 0 means no disturbance or neutral, while 10 means the highest level of disturban

Read more