What If You Feel Like You Are Thinking Too Much During EMDR?
Short Answer: If you feel like you are thinking too much during EMDR, you do not need to make your mind go blank. Thoughts, questions, and attempts to understand what is happening can arise during processing. The useful distinction is between noticing thoughts as they come and deliberately trying to analyze or control every part of the experience. When you catch yourself working hard to figure things out, return to the instructions for the session, notice what is present, and allow the next step to unfold without forcing a particular response.
Key Takeaways
- Thinking during EMDR is not automatically a problem, and you do not need an empty mind.
- Notice the difference between thoughts that arise naturally and deliberately analyzing each response.
- When you get caught in analysis, return to the session instructions and what you are noticing now.
- You can slow down, pause, or describe what is happening rather than trying to force yourself to process differently.
What Does Thinking Too Much During EMDR Feel Like?
You may notice yourself asking why a memory appeared, whether a thought is important, or what you should be feeling next. You might mentally review the same detail several times or try to work out whether the session is going as expected. These are examples of thinking about the process while you are in it.
Some thoughts are simply part of what comes up when you focus on a memory. Others involve stepping back to judge, explain, or direct the experience. Both can happen during an EMDR session, and a moment of analysis does not mean you have done something wrong.
The concern is not the number of thoughts you have. It is whether you are spending so much effort interpreting them that you have stopped following the activity in front of you. Recognizing that difference gives you a practical way to respond.
Are You Supposed to Stop Thinking During EMDR?
No. EMDR does not require you to switch off your thoughts or hold your mind in a completely quiet state. Memories often bring up words, ideas, images, emotions, and body sensations. A thought can be one of the things you notice during a round.
Trying to prevent every thought can become another task to manage. You might start monitoring whether your mind is quiet enough and then feel distracted by that monitoring. There is no need to create this extra requirement.
Instead, follow the particular instructions for the stage of EMDR you are doing. When asked what you noticed, an honest answer might be a memory detail, a physical sensation, a thought, or very little at all. You do not need to make the answer sound more emotional or less intellectual.
The goal is not to choose the correct type of experience. It is to observe the experience that is actually there.
What Is the Difference Between Noticing and Analyzing?
Noticing means recognizing what came up. You might think, “I remembered the sound of the door,” or “I am wondering why that moment stands out.” You can acknowledge the thought without immediately solving the question it raises.
Analyzing means moving into a longer effort to explain, compare, or evaluate. For example, you might start reconstructing the entire event, deciding which interpretation is accurate, or checking whether a particular thought proves that you are making progress.
There is nothing inherently wrong with reflecting on your experiences. The distinction matters because EMDR has a session structure. During a processing round, extended analysis may draw your attention away from simply noticing what comes next.
If you realize you have been analyzing, you do not need to criticize yourself. Recognize it, and return to the task the session has asked you to do.
Why Might You Start Trying to Figure Everything Out?
When you are working with a meaningful memory, it can be natural to want an explanation. You may want to know why a certain detail bothers you, why an unexpected association appeared, or whether your response is changing.
You may also be trying to follow the process carefully. If the instructions ask you to notice what comes up, it is easy to turn that into a search for something significant. You might begin looking for the “right” thought rather than describing what you actually noticed.
Sometimes analysis begins when little seems to be happening. You may fill the quiet moment by reviewing the memory, predicting the next response, or deciding that you should be feeling something different.
None of these possibilities needs to become a separate problem to solve during the session. The first useful step is simply noticing that you have shifted from experiencing the round to evaluating it.
What Can You Do When You Catch Yourself Overthinking?
Start with a simple acknowledgment. You might notice, “I am trying to work this out,” without turning that observation into another long discussion with yourself. There is no need to suppress the thought or argue with it.
Next, return to the current instruction. If you are in a processing round, attend to the target or whatever the session directs you to notice. If it is time to report what came up, describe it plainly. You can say that you were thinking about the memory rather than feeling a clear change.
You do not have to replace analysis with a particular emotion or image. Trying to manufacture a different response is another form of control. Let the answer be as ordinary or as unexpected as it is.
If you keep losing track of the instructions, you can pause and orient yourself to the step you are on. A brief reset is often more useful than pushing through while trying to manage several tasks at once.
Can You Think About the Meaning of a Memory?
Yes. Thoughts about meaning can arise naturally during EMDR. You may notice a new perspective on an old event, recognize a connection between two experiences, or question a belief you previously held. Those thoughts are part of what you can report.
The difference is whether a new perspective appears on its own or you are trying to reason your way to one because you think the session requires it. You do not need to reach an insight after each round.
For example, noticing “I was younger than I remembered” is different from spending the next several minutes trying to prove what that realization means. Both involve thinking, but only the second becomes a deliberate analysis project.
If you want to reflect further, you can make a short note after the session. That allows you to remember the thought without requiring yourself to resolve it in the middle of processing.
What If You Keep Checking Whether EMDR Is Working?
Another common form of overthinking is repeatedly checking your progress. You may wonder whether a memory is less vivid, whether a disturbance rating should be lower, or whether you are noticing the right changes.
EMDR includes designated moments for checking aspects of your response. Those check-ins are more useful when you answer them honestly rather than continuously measuring yourself between them.
If you find yourself testing the memory over and over, return to the activity the session is asking you to complete. A single round does not need to produce a visible change, and you do not need to interpret every thought as evidence for or against progress.
At a scheduled check-in, give the rating or description that fits. Between check-ins, allow yourself to notice what comes up without turning each observation into a score.
When Might a Pause Be More Helpful Than Another Round?
If you have spent several rounds trying to solve questions about the memory, another round is not automatically the best response. Consider whether you are still able to follow the session steps and notice your experience without constantly directing it.
A short pause can give you room to stop evaluating each response. You can check where you are in the process and decide whether continuing fits the instructions and your current pace.
If you are working with a therapist, let them know when you find yourself repeatedly analyzing your thoughts instead of following the processing exercise. If you are using a self-guided program such as Virtual EMDR, you can pause and review the instructions before deciding whether to continue. In either approach, taking a moment to refocus can be more helpful than pushing through another round while distracted by your own analysis.
Pausing does not require you to conclude that thinking was a failure. It is simply one available way to keep the session manageable and purposeful.
How Can You Reflect After the Session Without Overanalyzing?
After the session, you may want to remember a thought that stood out. A short note can help. Write down the memory or target, the main observation, and anything you want to revisit later. You do not need a detailed explanation of why every thought appeared.
It can also help to separate what you noticed from what you think it means. “I remembered a conversation” is an observation. “That conversation must explain everything” is an interpretation. Keeping those separate makes your notes more accurate.
If you want to explore a question further, choose a suitable time rather than trying to settle it immediately. Not every association needs an answer, and some thoughts may remain ordinary passing thoughts.
The purpose of notes is to support your memory of the session, not to grade the quality of your processing. A simple record is enough.
Conclusion
Feeling like you are thinking too much during EMDR does not mean you must stop having thoughts. The useful question is whether you are noticing what arises or working hard to explain and control every response. Thoughts can be part of the experience without becoming a task you must solve.
When you catch yourself analyzing, return to the current session instruction and describe what you genuinely notice. Use the planned check-ins instead of constantly measuring progress, and pause when you need to. You can take the process seriously without trying to manage every thought it brings up.
View Comments